West Ham Online

Exciting day so far in the PL

The keeper had a clear view of the ball all the time after Van Dijk headed it and wasn’t reaching it
To be honest given Robertson was 2yds from goal and as the corner came in he was trying to obstruct the keeper from coming out I don’t mind it being ruled out
Was less clear than that one a couple of years ago at Wolves when their offside player stayed in front of Fabianski when some bloke called Kilman headed in what he thought was a last minute equaliser 

If you have to duck in order for the ball to go into the net you are definitely interfering with play! I can’t believe that’s in debate. 
The very fact that the keeper could not track the ball with his eyes all the way to the goal because an offside Robertson was in front of the ball at a crucial point is the reason it’s disallowed. 
doesn’t matter if the keeper may or may not have reached the ball, he can’t see it fully cos Robertson is in the way. 


 

No he wasnt
He was standing in a line just inside the post where the ball went in
Keeper saw the ball clearly & despite a full length dive got nowhere near it. Or near Robertson 

Fauxstralian wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 19:04 Robertson was offside as there wasn’t a second City player between him and the goal
Was he influencing the goalkeepers vision of the ball or stopping the keeper saving it? No
But as the old saying goes if he isn’t influencing play why is he on the pitch
Quite happy to see any Liverpool goal disallowed
Hopefully Man City can get a run together & put Arsenal second again.

Dont be surprised to see Klopp back at Liverpool next season

 

Robertson was offside as there wasn’t a second City player between him and the goal
Was he influencing the goalkeepers vision of the ball or stopping the keeper saving it? No
But as the old saying goes if he isn’t influencing play why is he on the pitch
Quite happy to see any Liverpool goal disallowed
Hopefully Man City can get a run together & put Arsenal second again.

Dont be surprised to see Klopp back at Liverpool next season

I blame Clive Thomas who reffed the game, Lee was only doing what players do.

I hope Newcastle go down.

The Spurs of the North East.

Arrogant,  entitled cunts.

HA'WAY THE MACKEMS.

Still gutted that we missed out on Doku.

He's just what we need on the left.

It's funny how that fat Liverpool cսnt Sammy Lee wasn't offside because he was lying down against us in the league cup final. Now the boots on the other foot and they start crying, fuck 'em, hate the cunts.

Once Robertson ducked he became active. So offside. Oh and fuck 'em

Fauxstralian wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 17:27 Slot has spent £400m to make them worse
Jota & Diaz are big misses. Talented players who worked hard to let Salah loaf upfield 

City keeper wasn’t getting Van Dijks header but Robertson had to duck under it so his proximity could be argued as a distraction 
Though it really wasn’t. 

 

Slot has spent £400m to make them worse
Jota & Diaz are big misses. Talented players who worked hard to let Salah loaf upfield 

City keeper wasn’t getting Van Dijks header but Robertson had to duck under it so his proximity could be argued as a distraction 
Though it really wasn’t. 

I think once Forest get Chris Wood back Dyche will pull them clear
Hopefully we will get our shit together & it’s Wolves, Leeds & Burnley for the drop

Liverpool looking a poor side.

Weird that Ferret and COYI seem to just chat to each other on this thread

Newcastle lose away again 3-1. I thought they would struggle this season when I saw how poor they were on the opening day.

I think Howe is bang in trouble now. Could they get sucked into a relegation battle? I hope so.

Forest ahead. Could do with a Leeds equaliser here.

Two poor sides going at it at the City Ground.

Currently 1-1.

Still not forgiven Nuno for that selection at Leeds. That would’ve been a comfortable win with a decent lineup.

It IS poor form given Boro gave him a chance after it went pear shaped at Luton
Presumably has connections at Wolves
I have been to Wolverhampton and it IS closer to civilisation than Middlesbrough 

Fauxstralian wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 08:54 Supposedly Rob Edward’s contract has been suspended at Boro so looks likely to be going to Wolves
Why?
Money
Former Wolves player so has a connection to the club
Would prefer to live in Wolverhampton rather than chemical dump Middlesbrough 

Will do well to beat the tally he took Luton down with
Wolves trying a model of selling all their best players over the years …. Neves Neto Jimenez Cunha AltNouri etc etc
There is only one result when you do that

 

Sydney_Iron wrote: ↑09 Nov 2025, 01:44 Been sympathising with Arsenal fans on a PL forum, apparently, they were robbed? and Sunderland had the audacity to score from the only 2 "real" chances they had

And to top it off Arteta didn't get manager of the month for October, it went to Amorim! As i pointed out to them, its a real bummer when the "big clubs" win these things when all can see how unjustified it is! 

Supposedly Rob Edward’s contract has been suspended at Boro so looks likely to be going to Wolves
Why?
Money
Former Wolves player so has a connection to the club
Would prefer to live in Wolverhampton rather than chemical dump Middlesbrough 

Will do well to beat the tally he took Luton down with
Wolves trying a model of selling all their best players over the years …. Neves Neto Jimenez Cunha AltNouri etc etc
There is only one result when you do that

Been sympathising with Arsenal fans on a PL forum, apparently, they were robbed? and Sunderland had the audacity to score from the only 2 "real" chances they had

And to top it off Arteta didn't get manager of the month for October, it went to Amorim! As i pointed out to them, its a real bummer when the "big clubs" win these things when all can see how unjustified it is! 

Tomshardware wrote: ↑08 Nov 2025, 22:48

Sweep wrote: ↑08 Nov 2025, 21:33 Wolves 0-2 at Chelsea .

2 points from 11 games...has any club ever recovered from that?

Don't think any club has recovered from 2 points from first 11 games.   Even the Derby County team from 07/08 season had 6 points from 11 games.   I don't get why Edwards would leave a team with a decent chance of promotion to manage a team who look certain for relegation.

Sweep wrote: ↑08 Nov 2025, 21:33 Wolves 0-2 at Chelsea .

2 points from 11 games...has any club ever recovered from that?